Outcome-based Performance Metrics in Canadian Health Care: Moving from “How Many” to “How Well”

Performance in the health sector has conventionally been viewed in terms of volumes, such as the number of additional surgeries that were performed in a given year. Unfortunately, health status and outcomes are not routinely assessed in Canada. This is a substantive concern — imagine the case where your car manufacturer's performance metric did not include car safety and performance but merely focused on production volume. Health status is a more appropriate outcome than volume for assessing system performance, and understanding variation in performance of the health system provides the opportunity to improve patients’ health-related quality of life. This study aims to develop a system to assess the performance of the health care system by measuring what it produces in terms of "health," such as health-related quality of life rather than only measuring the "production of health care" — for example, surgical volumes.

Dr. Jennifer Davis' research will address the use and analysis of “performance metrics” within health care, with a particular focus on patient-centred and outcome-based measures using Patient Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs). PROMs are detailed surveys that allow patients to report important changes as a result of a medical intervention and allow the assessment of health-related quality of life. Thus, instead of just measuring that a surgery took place, PROMs measure the patient’s perception of how the surgery has improved their life.

Dr. Davis will be applying knowledge from fields outside the health care sector, such as engineering and education, to improve performance assessment within the health care sector. By determining how specific measures improve performance outcomes in other fields, and by identifying which of these are most effective, she will then specifically determine the potential to adapt these measures as PROMS within the health care context to enhance the health of Canadians. This critical platform will enable the first performance assessments using a patient-centred and outcome-based approach in Canada.

Pathophysiological contributions of T-type calcium channel variation towards thalamocortical network hyperexcitability and absence epilepsy

More than 50 million people worldwide suffer from epilepsy. Approximately 90 percent of those treated with current drugs experience significant side effects, and around 30 percent do not respond to current medical treatments at all. Therefore, significantly better treatments are required to improve the quality of life for epilepsy sufferers in Canada and worldwide. To achieve this, a far greater understanding of how the brain works both normally and during seizures is necessary.

Epilepsy is a difficult disorder to study in humans; however, in the 1980s, a strain of rats that naturally suffer from a type of seizure very similar to the human condition and involving the same brain regions was identified. These rats are extremely useful in helping us understand the causes of epilepsy in humans and test new drugs being developed to treat epilepsy. Two years ago, Dr. Stuart Cain’s research characterized a newly discovered genetic mutation in the epileptic rat strain responsible for a large portion of seizures. Epileptic seizures can be caused by changes in the way certain brain nerve cell proteins, known as "calcium channels," conduct electricity — the mutation characterized by Dr. Cain alters the way in which a specific type of calcium channel conducts electrical signaling. This was significant as these particular calcium channels are able to generate patterns of electrical pulses, known as “firing patterns,” predicted to contribute to epileptic seizures.

Dr. Cain’s research project aims to determine how the calcium channel mutation alters communication between nerve cells and affects different firing patterns. His laboratory is the only site in North America currently studying the epileptic rat strain. Understanding what causes the firing properties of epileptic nerves to change during seizures should allow the design of new drug treatments with the ability to block these changes directly, and to also reduce side effects compared to many of the broad-target drugs currently used clinically.

Improving Enzymatic Removal of Major Blood Antigens

Blood transfusion is a critically important medical procedure used to treat blood loss due to trauma or during surgery; it is also used in the treatment of chronic blood disorders such as thalassemia, sickle-cell disease and other forms of anemia. Due to the presence of blood antigens, however, careful blood typing is necessary to avoid the adverse and sometimes fatal reactions that may result from a mismatched blood type during transfusion. The A and B blood antigens are considered the most clinically important blood antigens. These antigens consist of carbohydrate (sugar) molecules attached to the surface of blood cells. People with type O blood lack the A and B antigens on their red blood cells and thus are often considered “”universal donors”” (not accounting for minor antigens), yet units of type O blood are frequently in short supply due to high demand. The use of enzymes to remove A and B antigens is a potential means of generating universal blood donor cells from blood types other than O. Dr. David Kwan’s research aims to investigate methods for the enzymatic removal of blood antigens from blood cells. Although enzymes that remove the A or B antigens to convert red blood cells have been discovered, they have low efficacy. Recently a new enzyme called EABase was discovered, which can efficiently remove the B antigen but only slowly removes the A antigen from red blood cells. The primary focus of Dr. Kwan’s work will be to engineer the EABase enzyme using “”directed evolution”” techniques to improve the efficiency of EABase in removing blood antigens so that it may be a more efficient catalyst for the conversion of A-, B- and AB-type red blood cells into “”universal blood cells.”” A secondary focus, in collaboration with the Centre for Blood Research, will test the use of polymer additives to enhance the rate of enzyme action. Over 15 million units (approximately 450 ml per unit) are collected for preparation of blood products in Canada and the United States per year. The ability to generate universal blood donor cells would be a breakthrough development, allowing transfusion without the need to find a positive match and tremendously improving the supply of blood while increasing the safety of blood transfusions.

Cerebral and coronary vascular reactivity in patients at risk for myocardial infarction and stroke using advanced imaging and blood gas control techniques

Cardiovascular disease, including heart attack and stroke, is a major public health concern. The Public Health Agency of Canada indicates that 37 per cent of all deaths in Canada are cardiovascular in origin and approximately 10 per cent of hospitalizations in Canada are related to heart disease or stroke. Cardiovascular risk is currently estimated by assessing risk factors such as smoking status, height, weight, and the amount of cholesterol in the blood. Alternate methods such as viewing the heart and brain with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) could be more useful, as they would help physicians detect and treat impairments in vascular function much earlier, thus reducing cardiovascular disease risk. Dr. Glen Foster wants to find out how measurements of vascular function are related to stroke or heart disease risk by assessing blood vessel function in patients at risk for both diseases. He is defining the relationship between brain blood vessel function and stroke, and heart vessel function and heart disease, by comparing patients who have recently suffered strokes or heart attacks with subjects who are in low- or high-risk groups for either of these conditions. He will be working with a number of colleagues at UBC who have designed a unique system capable of manipulating and controlling blood oxygen and carbon dioxide content within the MRI scanner to examine changes in vascular function in response. Using the MRI to measure vascular function throughout the vessels of the heart and brain, while accurately controlling the blood oxygen and carbon dioxide, is an important new idea in the clinical setting. This leading-edge concept could revolutionize sub-clinical detection of cardiovascular disease; it could help track how effective treatment is and provide new information in the specific anatomical area of heart disease and stroke.

Towards a patient-specific model of facial skin

Complex surgical procedures on the face, such as jaw reconstruction, frequently result in problematic scars that may be aesthetically upsetting for the patient or can interfere with chewing or swallowing. An accurate facial computer model of a patient’s face could allow surgeons to test different surgical incision pattern designs before surgery to determine which design is likely to result in the best outcome. A computer model of a patient’s face must take into account the complex properties of facial skin, such as the variability of stretch depending on direction. This requires experimental data from tests on a real human face; however, there is little data available at present about the stiffness of facial skin and soft tissues. The goal of Dr. Cormac Flynn’s research is to determine how the complex properties of facial skin affect our chewing and swallowing actions and how facial scars interfere with these functions. He aims to develop a computer model of the face with the most accurate representation of facial skin possible. To do this, he will use a biomedical device to determine the stiffness and thickness of skin and soft tissue below the skin surface of volunteers. His second task will be to use a small robotic device to apply small forces to a volunteer’s face and measure how much the skin surface deforms. The force will be applied to a number of points on the face in succession to provide a rich set of data that will be used to develop the skin model. Dr. Flynn will determine appropriate computer models to represent the skin and underlying soft tissue and apply his data from the first two experiments to set the parameters. Finally, he will merge the face model with an existing computer model of the jaw and tongue developed at UBC. The ability of the resulting model to simulate chewing and swallowing will be compared with existing computer models. This research will provide crucial knowledge about how facial skin and the underlying soft tissues influence chewing and swallowing, and will be used in the development of a computer model that surgeons can use to improve both reconstructive surgery outcomes and quality of life for patients.

The role of IL-17 in the pathogenesis of type-1 diabetes

Type 1 diabetes, also known as juvenile diabetes, is an autoimmune disease that usually presents in children and young adults. In patients with Type 1 diabetes, the body attacks itself, thus destroying insulin-producing cells in the pancreas that regulate blood sugar (glucose). A diagnosis of Type 1 diabetes currently translates to a lifetime burden of insulin injections and a risk of multiple complications for children in Canada. T-cells are white blood cells and play a key role in the immune system to control infection. In healthy individuals, a type of T-cell, called Th17, provides a strong defense by guiding the immune system to attack bacteria and virus-infected targets within our bodies. A recent discovery of elevated numbers of Th17 cells in children newly diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes suggests that these cells may play a key role in the early development of this disease in young patients. Interestingly, Th17 cells have been associated with other autoimmune diseases, such as Crohn’s disease and multiple sclerosis. Dr. Ashish Marwaha is working to identify novel treatments for Type 1 diabetes by understanding the function of Th17 cells in the course of a child developing Type 1 diabetes. To understand if there is a specific genetic mutation that can predict which children will have high levels of Th17 cells and therefore at risk of developing Type 1 diabetes, he will be analyzing stored blood samples from British Columbian children with this disease. The findings from this study will determine the extent to which Th17 cells are harmful in Type 1 diabetes and may open the door to new treatments for childhood diabetes that target Th17 cells.

Developing Whole Brain and Spinal Cord Markers of Pathology in Neuromyelitis Optica and Multiple Sclerosis

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is an autoimmune disease of the brain and spinal cord (together termed the central nervous system), where inflammation of the myelin coating of nerves leads to cell damage and varying degrees of disability. Neuromyelitis optica (NMO) is another inflammatory demyelinating disease of the central nervous system; however, it differs from MS in a few subtle but important aspects. NMO primarily affects the optic nerves and spinal cord, and evidence suggests that the flow of water in cells is very important in NMO. The similar characteristics of MS and NMO make it difficult to differentiate between the two; however, patient prognosis and optimal treatment for these two diseases are very different. Dr. Shannon Kolind is working to develop a non-invasive quantitative imaging tool for assessing both myelin and total water content throughout the entire central nervous system with the aim of differentiating between MS and NMO in terms of disease processes, diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment outcome. She is using a newly-developed magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) technique that is sensitive and specific to myelin and allows for high-resolution imaging of the brain and spinal cord in clinically feasible times. This technique can also be modified to estimate total water content. Dr. Kolind is using this technique to study the regional differences in myelin and inflammation in areas of focal damage (known as lesions) in MS and NMO, as well as areas of the brain and spinal cord that appear normal but might also have important damage. Ultimately, this research will provide new sensitive and specific imaging markers of excess water (inflammation/edema), myelin health (neuroprotection), myelin loss (neurodegeneration) and myelin repair (remyelination). The importance of this project lies in two potential improvements to the lives of people with MS and NMO. Rapidly and accurately making a diagnosis has a major impact on quality of life by determining the most effective treatment; it also reduces the stress of uncertainty, particularly with regard to prognosis. Furthermore, developing imaging markers and relating them to clinical symptoms will allow easier and more reliable monitoring and prediction of disease progression, which will aid in clinical trials of potential therapies, ultimately leading to the earlier availability of successful treatments.

The role of altered palmitoylation of synaptic proteins in synaptic function/dysfunction in a mouse model of Huntington’s disease

Within each individual cell, different proteins are localized to specific and necessary locations. There are many different ways these proteins are directed to where they need to go. One method for influencing protein localization is palmitoylation, which is the addition of a lipid molecule, specifically palmitate, to the protein. Protein localization is especially important in neurons, where synaptic proteins need to be carefully organized and localized to the pre- and post-synaptic regions of the neuron in order to accurately convey messages from one neuron to another. In Huntington's disease, which is characterized by neuronal death and subsequent severe motor and cognitive disturbances, it appears that synaptic proteins are mis-localized outside of the synapse, which causes synaptic dysfunction prior to cell death and symptom onset. Preventing this early synaptic dysfunction is believed to be a viable means of preventing or significantly delaying cell death and Huntington’s disease symptoms. Previous work has suggested that the level of palmitoylation is decreased in Huntington’s disease and that this may contribute to early synaptic protein dysfunction. Dr. Matthew Parsons is working to determine how the palmitoylation of specific synaptic proteins regulates their localization within the synapse and how this relates to the synaptic dysfunction observed in Huntington’s disease. Specifically, he is using different techniques to compare the properties of synaptic communication, synaptic protein localization and neuronal vulnerability to cell death in mice that have Huntington’s disease and mice with reduced protein palmitoylation. He will also use neuronal cultures from wild-type animals to investigate the effects of experimentally manipulated protein palmitoylation. Should the synaptic dysfunction due to decreased palmitoylation resemble the synaptic dysfunction in Huntington’s disease, he will also attempt to rescue the early Huntington’s disease phenotype by overexpression of a protein known to promote palmitoylation. These studies will help determine whether the regulation of synaptic protein palmitoylation may be a viable target for the treatment of Huntington’s disease.

The role of astrocytes in the brain vascular response to neural activity

Sufficient blood flow to the brain is critical for normal brain function. In response to increased brain activity, a local increase in blood flow to the active area is required to supply extra oxygen and glucose. This increase in blood flow is controlled by signaling molecules, which are released by neurons and astrocytes and can regulate blood vessel diameter. Dr. Clare Howarth will investigate how brain blood flow is controlled in response to increases in brain activity and how this is impaired in disease. In particular, she will be studying the role that astrocytes, a type of brain cell, play in the regulation of brain blood flow. One of the signaling molecules released by astrocytes, prostaglandin E2, can result in blood vessel dilation. Dr. Howarth’s hypothesis is that following a stroke, astrocytes have a decreased ability to produce prostaglandin E2, and this contributes to the long-lasting failure of blood vessels to dilate, leading to increasing neuronal damage. Using multi-photon imaging techniques, she will observe what happens to blood flow in the brain when astrocytes are stimulated with pharmaceutical or light-activated agents under conditions where the production of these signaling molecules is compromised. She will also investigate whether pharmaceutical therapies are able to reverse the effect, allowing blood vessels to dilate and help recover brain function after a stroke. This work will advance our understanding of how brain blood flow is regulated in response to neural activity. This knowledge is essential to understanding normal brain function, functional imaging techniques, and what occurs when the brain energy supply is cut off in disorders such as a stroke.

Identification of antigens for disease associated public T-cells

Circulating T-cells are the key players in our adaptive immune system and are particularly important for recognizing and killing cells that are infected with viruses or carry cancer-causing mutations. T-cells have the ability to potentially recognize vast numbers of different infectious agents and cancer- or tumour-associated mutations. The T-cell receptor, on the surface of the T-cell, is responsible for this task, and the variation required for recognition is generated mainly by shuffling the large number of short DNA segments that comprise T-cell receptor genes. Although the central importance of the T-cell receptor in adaptive immunity is well established, the actual number and diversity of T-cells that exist in an individual (i.e. the T-cell repertoire), how this changes in response to immune challenge, and how it varies from one individual to the next, remains a mystery. Dr. Rob Holt’s lab is using the latest DNA sequencing technologies to directly sequence T-cell receptor genes in order to examine the T-cell repertoire in a given blood sample. Using this approach, the lab has identified populations of unique T-cell repertoires in bone marrow stem cell transplant patients and in colorectal cancer patients. Dr. Kristoffer Palma’s research project is to take this approach one step further by developing a novel, high-throughput screen for the molecular patterns (antigens) recognized by donor T-cells and to find out how these are related to transplant success in bone marrow transplants. The second application of his research is to determine if there are T-cell receptor commonalities in patients with colorectal cancer tumours, how T-cell receptor commonalities relate to disease prognosis, and what tumour-associated antigens may be recognized by T-cells in patients with high survival rates. In the case of bone marrow transplants, Palma anticipates that his research will lead towards the earlier diagnosis and intervention in graft versus host disease, which is the most immediate and life-threatening complication of bone marrow transplant, affecting 30 to 80 per cent of patients. With regard to colorectal cancer, Palma hopes his research will contribute to the creation of a high-resolution diagnostic screening test to identify early stage cancer that would be undetectable with current assays and aid in the eventual development of cancer-specific vaccines.